Showing posts with label neil degrasse tyson. Show all posts
Showing posts with label neil degrasse tyson. Show all posts

Sunday, June 8, 2014

Cosmos Episode 13 Thoughts

Well, that's it for Cosmos: A Spacetime Odyssey.  This last episode was very contemplative, as it should have been.  As is tradition in Cosmos, we started off in one of the most interesting and far-thinking places of the ancient world: the Library of Alexandria.  Sure, the ancients were far from perfect, and the knowledge collected there was only for a select few.  But for several hundred years, the Library was dedicated to the collection of all the knowledge in the ancient world, and the city of Alexandria became a metropolis of not just Egypt, but the entire world.  People there were citizens of a broader universe then the relatively small Nile delta the city sits on.  Athens and Rome may have been great cities, the centers of glorious civilizations, but there would not be another city like Alexandria for a very, very long time.

A good portion of the episode was spent on dark matter.  The idea of dark matter was first brought up by crazy old Fritz Zwicky back in the 1930's, but with no good evidence to back up his claim, that idea was forgotten.  At the time, the idea of dark matter was silly.  40 years later, scientists began looking at the rotation of galaxies, watching the stars orbit around, anticipating that stars in the outer portion of the galaxy would move much slower than stars in a closer orbit, just like the planets in the outer solar system move slower than the ones in the inner solar system.  This went against everything we knew about gravity.  There were two option, either Einstein and Newton were completely wrong, or there was something there that we couldn't see exerting a whole lot of gravity on these galaxies.  That something is dark matter.  It took a long time for Zwicky's idea to be proven correct, and it very easily could have been wrong.  Scientists of the 1930's were perfectly capable, but their equipment was just not up to the task, and nobody bothered to look.  As it turns out, all the visible matter in the universe, every last bit of it, is only about 5% of the total mass of the universe.  A third of it is dark matter, and the rest is the even more mysterious dark energy, which is pushing the universe apart at an accelerating rate.

You could argue about what mankind's greatest achievement has been, but the Voyager space probes are definitely near the top of that list.  For the first time, we built something that is going beyond the solar system, beyond any influence of Earth, into the great unknown.  Maybe one day somebody will  read the messages they bear, or maybe one day our own descendents will stumble across them after all knowledge of them has been lost to time.  But they're out there, and of course, they are responsible for one of the greatest images ever taken: the Pale Blue Dot.  We got quite a bit of Carl Sagan as we heard his thoughts on this absolutely incredible image, and that picture is every bit as evocative now as it was then.  Our planet, as big as it seems to us, is reduced to a single, slightly blue pixel in a vast, empty space.  Everything we know and have ever known is on that pixel.  Frankly, I can't imagine someone going, "Well, I know enough right now."  The thought of a infinite universe that I can never fully understand is more comforting to me.  I would go so far as to say that I hope I never do learn everything there is to know about the universe, because what would I do with infinite knowledge?  It would be boring.

The series closes with a meditation on science itself.  We hear about the importance of a free society where ideas can be discussed without fear of censure or retribution.  We learn about the importance of challenging authority, that nobody can tell you that something is true without first giving you actual proof.  The importance of experimentation, and the thing that I found most important, that everyone, even the greatest scientists, can be wrong.  Nobody is right about everything, because we are all only human.  Science is a tool, but we can misuse it, and it is our duty to make sure science does not get misused.  I think that was the most relevant point made in this series.  The original Cosmos introduced science to the masses, before that, nobody had ever attempted such an ambitious show on science on national TV.  This Cosmos recognizes that it doesn't need to do the same thing, instead, it needed to remind us about what science really is, how it's being misused, and what we can do to claim it again for all the people of Earth.  We don't want science to be held by the elite, we want science to be for everyone.  So while the two series might be different in a lot of ways, in that one way, they are the same, and that's what's important.

My Other Blogs
Loose on the Internet
Cool Golf News

My Twitter

Sunday, June 1, 2014

Cosmos Episode 12 Thoughts

There was no episode last week, but there was today.  This was the second-to-last episode if the series, and the tone has definitely changed.  This Cosmos was always going to be different from the first one, and it definitely showed tonight.  The original focused more on revealing the wonders of the universe to a world that had never seen such things, this series exists more of a reminder and a gentle admonition of our rather lackluster stewardship of the planet.  Carl Sagan told us about our place in the universe and what we need to do to better the planet, Neil deGrasse Tyson is pushing us to follow through with our responsibilities.

Tonight was all about carbon dioxide.  It's a simple molecule, one carbon atom, two oxygen atoms, but it is responsible for so much.  Plants couldn't function without it, and without plants, there would be no animals, no people.  Without carbon dioxide in the atmosphere, the planet would be frozen solid.  Life depends on carbon dioxide's property as a greenhouse gas, but there has to be a balance.  There is a planet in our solar system which shows us what happens when there is too much carbon dioxide, and it's right next door.  Both series have made allusions to Venus when talking about the greenhouse effect, and while Earth will never be as bad as Venus, it will take less than we think to make Earth a very harsh place.

It's not like this is a recent thing, the issue about global warming.  We've known about it for a long time, and as we learned tonight, there were multiple junctures throughout history where we could have gone down a path of clean, renewable energy.  Unfortunately, the great tides of society were never on the side of solar power, instead always moving towards cheap fossil fuels.  Now is the time for a switch to be made, and the transition is happening, but it is slow and painful, we are dragging it out with fossil fuels until the bitter end.  Big energy companies will give us clean energy eventually, but only after getting every last dollar out of fossil fuels, and for a nation that loves to criticize big business, we sure seem happy to keep doing what we're doing.  Maybe Tyson will have something to say about that in the finale, maybe not, actually, I hope not.  I don't want the series to end with an indictment of what we've done, but rather look out and to the future, to a brighter time for mankind.

My Other Blogs
Loose on the Internet
Cool Golf News

My Twitter

Sunday, May 18, 2014

Cosmos Episode 11 Thoughts

We're getting down towards the end of the series, and the discussion is starting to get a bit more serious.  Tonight, the show was about the persistence of life, and the pursuit of all life to attain immortality.  Life would simply not work if it was not able to weather the harshest of conditions or do whatever it takes to survive.

Life on Earth has taken many routes to ensure its own survival.  There are bacteria that can survive the vacuum of space and being frozen in ice for millions of years.  If these organisms can handle these conditions, would it not be unreasonable that life could have migrated here from somewhere else, or that Earth itself has colonized another world with our own life?  There are bacteria with extraordinary abilities that go unused on Earth, so why have them at all, if they evolved on Earth?  It's an interesting thought, although I am still in favor of life on Earth being native to Earth.  I'm just not sure if bacteria really could make the journey in between worlds like that.

I think there was a missed opportunity when Tyson discussed dandelions and the adaptation their seeds possess, floating on the wind for hundreds of miles to settle new and unknown areas.  The dandelion was a very important symbol in the original Cosmos for that reason, the Ship of the Imagination was a dandelion seed.  I guess since they already quoted the original show before, they didn't want too many references in one episode.  It would have been nice though.

When it comes to achieving immortality, humanity has an advantage.  We invented writing, we have a way to permanently preserve our thoughts, our feelings, our history for all time.  We can learn from past mistakes, we are endlessly adaptable, and of course, we are intelligent.  Humanity has so many things going for it, there is no good reason for our species not to endure indefinitely.  Sometimes now, it does feel like we are permanently sabotaging ourselves, and the worst part is that we know we're doing it.  Maybe this time will seem better when viewing it through the eyes of history, and many things have improved dramatically.  It just feels like we could do better.

My Other Blogs
Loose on the Internet
Cool Golf News

My Twitter